Building a compelling case for prevention – Phase 1
Project title: Developing a compelling case for prevention
This project is finished, read the final report for Phase 1 here, or find out about Phase 2 here.
What is the issue?
Chronic diseases are a serious and increasing problem. The associated economic burden not only affects individuals and the health system, it also adversely affects workplace productivity, economic growth and participation across the full range of domestic and workplace activities.
Fortunately, many major chronic diseases are largely preventable through changes to key risk factors: poor diet, physical inactivity, tobacco use, harmful alcohol consumption and obesity.
Despite the burden of lifestyle-related chronic disease and the opportunities for prevention, only a small percentage of Australian government budgets for health care is spent on prevention.
How did the project address the issue?
The overall objectives of the project were to:
- Demonstrate the scale and scope of benefits from preventing the most prevalent modifiable risk factors, namely poor diet, physical inactivity, tobacco use, harmful alcohol consumption and overweight and obesity
- Develop and demonstrate the value of a range of interventions to reduce preventable chronic disease, assessing both effectiveness and value for money
- Develop and make readily available innovative, accessible and compelling messaging about the value of reducing preventable chronic disease.
The project had three main parts:
- Literature review and data collation – The project team collated evidence about the health and economic burden of chronic disease, its preventability and the economic credentials for action. The literature review covered both methodology and empirical results.
- Dynamic simulation modelling – Dynamic simulation modelling is a tool that enables policy makers to test the likely impact of a range of possible policy solutions in computer models before implementing them in the real world. The project developed a dynamic simulation model to demonstrate the value of prevention to reduce lifestyle-related chronic diseases, and the associated impact on the costs of health service use and the increase in health and wellbeing in Australia. The model integrated evidence about the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of prevention interventions and strategies, with expert opinion to develop the models.
- Communications – The team also developed innovative and accessible resources to communicate the model outputs.
What were the outcomes?
- A proof-of-concept demonstration of the potential of dynamic simulation methods to make a compelling case for investing in prevention of chronic disease, this engaging and useful tool can be used to illustrate the health benefits and economic value of prevention interventions to individuals, the health system and Australian productivity. This online simulation interface allows you to simulate hypothetical policy experiments using the limited interventions already included in the model structure.
- A literature review and data collation on the economic benefits of achieving feasible reductions in key lifestyle-related risk factors, including a major piece on productivity impact
- A suite of resources to creatively and effectively communicate the outputs of the model
- Readiness to respond at short notice to requests for evidence about the economics of prevention.
Relevance for practice
Although we can forecast the health burden of chronic diseases and the impact of individual risk factors, existing modelling does not consider what happens in the real world – for example, how interventions work in combination, or how people live with multiple risky behaviours that jointly influence the same preventable chronic disease.
Using the proof-of-concept model, users can understand how the assumptions behind interventions may or may not influence their impact at a population level by adjusting them if required, and can explore the change over time in the costs and benefits of strategies over time and on a number of health or economic indicators.
Prevention Centre policy partners are invited to engage with our online simulation interface to simulate policy experiments. The next phase of the project is to develop the proof-of-concept model into a robust decision-support tool for policy makers.
Note that the model requires further development before it is suitable for informing investment decisions.
Start date: February 2017
End date: June 2018
- Professor Rob Carter, Deakin University
- Dr Geoff McDonnell, Prevention Centre
- Professor Andrew Wilson, Prevention Centre
- Jacqueline Davison, Prevention Centre
- Mark Heffernan, System Dynamics Modeller
- Jaithri Ananthapavan, Deakin University
- Paul Crosland, Deakin University
- Michael Lambert, Sax Institute
- Associate Professor Jo-An Atkinson, Sax Institute
- Helen Signy, Prevention Centre
- Emma Slaytor, Prevention Centre
- Louise Freebairn, ACT Health
- Kathleen Graham, Data Officer, ACT Health
- Glenn Draper, ACT Health
- Oscar Yang, Australian Institute of Health and Welfare
- Cathy Watson, ACT Health
- Philip Hull, ACT Health
- Alex DuMais, Prevention Centre
- Kurt Kreuger, Prevention Centre
- Dylan Knowles, Prevention Centre
- Wade MacDonald, Prevention Centre
- Annie Wang, Prevention Centre
We acknowledge the invaluable input into this project of our colleague, mentor, and above-all friend, Associate Professor Sonia Wutzke (1970–2017). The public health community is richer for having had you as one of its most passionate advocates.
This project was funded by the NHMRC, Australian Government Department of Health, NSW Ministry of Health, ACT Health and the HCF Research Foundation.
This project has now been completed. The final outcomes are listed below.
An initial online simulation interface has been developed as a proof-of-concept to allow Prevention Centre policy partners to simulate policy experiments using the limited interventions already included in the model structure. Users of the interface are able to understand the assumptions behind these interventions, adjust them if required, and explore the costs and benefits of the impact of these strategies over time and on a number of health or economic indicators.
In addition, three agent-based models of priority issues to our policy partner, ACT Health, were constructed: smoking behaviour and environmental restrictions, excessive alcohol consumption and the food legislative
This system dynamics model represents a significant advancement in conceptualisation and scope with respect to previous single risk factor population and burden models. The project has enabled the Prevention Centre to establish that the system dynamics of preventable chronic disease burden can be modelled. Prior to this model only individual risk factors and several outcomes of interest had been successfully modelled using system dynamic techniques in the health policy sphere in Australia.
It is important to note that the model is still a work-in-progress and should not be used to inform investment decisions. However, the Prevention Centre has refunded the project to expand the scope of the model until November 2020. Read more about the second phase of the project here.
- Final Report – Phase 1. Building a compelling case for prevention: Computational modelling of health and economic benefits of chronic disease prevention interventions in Australia (PDF 2.3MB)
- Crosland P, Ananthapavan J, Davison J, Lambert M, Carter R. The health burden of preventable disease in Australia: a systematic review. Aust NZ J Public Health. Online. doi: 10.1111/1753-6405.12882
- Freebairn L. Stopping before you start: Reducing and preventing initiation of tobacco use. ModSim 2019 Conference, 23rd International Congress on Modelling and Simulation, Canberra, 2 December 2019.
- Draper G. Development of a dynamic simulation model to estimate the impact of various policy options on alcohol consumption in the Australian Capital Territory. ModSim 2019 Conference, 23rd International Congress on Modelling and Simulation, Canberra, 2 December 2019.
- CCP Project Team. ACT Stakeholder Workshop: health economics, modelling update and agent-based modelling. 24-25 July 2018
- Crosland P, McDonnell G, Davison J, Heffernan M, Ananthapavan J, Carter R, Lambert M. Creating a compelling case for prevention: an integration of health economics, systems thinking and dynamic simulation modelling. Oral presentation at Fuze International Public Health Conference, Vancouver, Canada, May 2018. (Funded by Deakin Health Economics.)
- Davison J. Building a Compelling Case for Prevention [Menzies Health Policy/Uni Syd Emerging Health Policy Research Conference Sydney] July 2018
- Davison J. Building a Compelling Case for Prevention. PHAA Prevention Conference, Satellite Event. Simulation Modelling in Health Symposium. 4 May 2018.
- CCP Project Team, various presentations. Stakeholder Workshop 2: modelling update and interventions. 20 February 2018
- CCP Project Team, various presentations. Stakeholder Workshop 1: Introduction to the Compelling Case for Prevention Workshop and collaborative model building exercise. 6 June 2017
Prevention Centre News
- February 2019, Australia’s first national model of chronic disease burden
- March 2018, Modelling drives innovation to prove the case for prevention
- June 2017, Making the compelling case for prevention